Manufacturing Is Officially Coming HomeManufacturing Is Officially Coming Home

Rob Spiegel

November 22, 2013

3 Min Read
Manufacturing Is Officially Coming Home

For the past three years, there has been mounting anecdotal evidence that North America is once again becoming a preferred location for manufacturing. The evidence has been spotty, but nonetheless compelling -- Apple's building in Texas, Motorola's making smartphones in Fort Worth, Lenovo opening a plant in North Carolina, Texas Instruments in Maine, GE in Kentucky. It goes on and on.

The growing list of North American plant openings has spurred the Association Connecting Electronics Industries (IPC) to conduct a study of onshoring -- the opposite of offshoring. Now in its second year, the study, "On-Shoring in the Electronics Industry: Trends and Outlook for North America," shows a pattern in the return or manufacturing to North America. "I think it is a trend. A lot of manufacturers are reviewing their strategy to see if the decisions they made in where they manufacture their products make sense," Sharon Starr, director of market research at IPC, told Design News.

Onshoring-graph-2.jpg

The survey confirms that companies are continuing to locate new operations in North America, and they are returning some existing operations to the region. The survey also finds that more onshoring is planned for the coming year. A representative sample of 92 companies with combined annual sales of $50 billion completed the survey.

The results also indicate that 16% of the responding companies moved operations to North America from overseas since the beginning of 2012. They include OEMs, EMS companies, PCB fabricators, and suppliers of materials and equipment. Based on the value of the operations and number of jobs created, EMS companies were responsible for the greatest share of operations returned to North America. Most of these operations were moved from China to the US, with a few moving to Mexico.

Starr points to a number of reasons companies are taking a closer look at North America as the right location for manufacturing. "The costs of offshore labor are going up in double digits," Starr told us. "Manufacturers are also factoring in costs they didn't anticipate, such as the need to send executives over to train, to hire, and to solve problems. That became quite a lot more than they anticipated."

Onshoring-graph-3.jpg

The low labor rate in Asia is turning out to be something of a mirage. "The labor rates between North America and Asia are narrowing in a couple ways. The wage rates in China are climbing at a fast pace, and they're not rising here," said Starr. "Also, productivity turned out to be an issue." All of that chips away at the labor advantage. Starr also pointed out that manufacturers are now considering the costs of transportation when they look overseas. "Logistics costs have risen dramatically," she said.

Starr noted that some offshoring costs were hard to determine before the manufacturer actually moved its plants to Asia. "Hidden costs included productivity and management costs," she said. "Manufacturers whose customers are in North America found it's important for fast turnaround and for design changes. The turnaround time and the pace of innovation become problematic when your manufacturing is across the world."

Last year, IPC started surveying manufacturers about their manufacturing location plans. "We'd been hearing a lot about onshoring. Some of it was a lot of talk, but we thought it would be a good service for the industry to find out if it was going on," said Starr. "This year we followed up on last year's survey to see if any more was being done. And it was."

Related posts:

About the Author

Rob Spiegel

Rob Spiegel serves as a senior editor for Design News. He started with Design News in 2002 as a freelancer covering sustainability issues, including the transistion in electronic components to RoHS compliance. Rob was hired by Design News as senior editor in 2011 to cover automation, manufacturing, 3D printing, robotics, AI, and more.

Prior to his work with Design News, Rob worked as a senior editor for Electronic News and Ecommerce Business. He served as contributing editolr to Automation World for eight years, and he has contributed to Supply Chain Management Review, Logistics Management, Ecommerce Times, and many other trade publications. He is the author of six books on small business and internet commerce, inclluding Net Strategy: Charting the Digital Course for Your Company's Growth.

He has been published in magazines that range from Rolling Stone to True Confessions.

Rob has won a number of awards for his technolloghy coverage, including a Maggy Award for a Design News article on the Jeep Cherokee hacking, and a Launch Team award for Ecommerce Business. Rob has also won awards for his leadership postions in the American Marketing Association and SouthWest Writers.

Before covering technology, Rob spent 10 years as publisher and owner of Chile Pepper Magazine, a national consumer food publication. He has published hundreds of poems and scores of short stories in national publications.

Sign up for Design News newsletters

You May Also Like