View Comments: Newest First|Oldest First|Threaded View
Page 1/3  >  >>
Cabe Atwell
User Rank
Re: Alternate solution
Cabe Atwell   1/20/2014 5:42:01 PM
It seems the simplest of solutions are often overlooked. Great story!

Rob Spiegel
User Rank
Re: Simple solution, poorly communicated. ---Simple?
Rob Spiegel   12/9/2013 12:02:54 PM
Thanks for the comments, Amclussen. They make a lot of sense.

User Rank
Reed Switch Ratings
JD_Daily   12/6/2013 10:32:43 PM
Reed type level switches do not have an inductive/capacitive load rating.  The ratings are in watts. For longest life a solid state relay should be used to switch power to relay coils, contactor coils, etc. Even with spike supression they should be applied at a small fraction of their rating to insure long life. 

User Rank
Re: Simple solution, poorly communicated. ---Simple?
Amclaussen   12/6/2013 7:29:04 PM
Dear Rob: Life has taught me things only appear to be that simple.

One of my favorite Murphy's Law statements (as I understand it), deals with comments (or thoughts) like yours... but Murphy was right: "When you seem to understand a simple thing, you are just appearing to fully understand it!

As you will see in many of the comments below, "simple" diode fixes aren't going to cut it. This story will appear simple enough to elicit "obvious" fixes, but there is always more if you look closely!

Dear tekochip, please read my statement about simple things... it applies equally well to seemingly "simple theory". Cheers, Amclaussen.

P.D.: I have dedicated a whole wall at my home shop to Murphy's corollaries, it helps me A LOT every day when I'm ready utter some profanity when building something and, as Murphy used to say, things got wrong!!! It is a white painted wall, and I add a new statement as soon as it happens to me... it has now about seven feet of writtings, yesterday I added the last one: "It happens that, during the reassembly of a part that requires a multitude of bolts, you happen to exclaim (at bolt number 15 of 16) "well, I've almost finished...", and then you reach for that last bolt to put it, when, suddenly, you realize that you forgot to place the gasket (and some gaskets look like smiling faces, to add insult to injury!).

User Rank
Re: What about inductive kickback?
Amclaussen   12/6/2013 7:02:03 PM
Good points, cookiejar!, and Yes, your post reveals your age, but in the good sense that you reflect your true experience, that truly comes with age, doesn't it? (now I'm showing MY age!).

BTW, the Tyco Application Note shows (very clearly) those spikes. as I was using an automotive, 12VDC, 40A relay, I didn't risk my old, school type scope!

User Rank
Re: Alternate solution: CALL THE MYTHBUSTERS!
Amclaussen   12/6/2013 6:39:12 PM
In regard to D.SHERMAN;

The simple diode "fix" has been repeated and repeated to become a myth!

As I suggested above (in response to Electron Wrangler), the problem with the reverse diode across the coil is that it slows the opening of the relay contacts, frequently reducing the contacts life -you end up protecting the switch sacrificing the relay contacts!-

Please see the excellent Application Note 13C3264 from Tyco. It will explain in detail all the related aspects involved in relay behavior and how the simple diode, mythified by all the people that use the easy web "Copy & Paste" knowledge dissemination attempt (without really performing a complete and through web search), has become an established Myth (call the Mythbusters NOW!). Best wishes to all. Amclaussen.

User Rank
What about inductive kickback?
cookiejar   12/6/2013 6:17:22 PM
You say you were driving relays through reed switches.  Your description and solution doesn't quite make sense to me. 

A relay coil is an inductive load.  An inductor won't allow quick changes in current just like a capacitor won't allow quick changes in voltage.  A relay coil by itself will not show a current spike on activation, but a relatively gradual increase in current.  But, when the circuit is open the inductance of the coil will try to keep the current flowing and can reach a very high voltage in its effort.  I've seen over 10,000 volts on a relay coil when the circuit is opened (on a C. P. Clare mercury-wetted reed relay - 15 Henry coil).  The resultant arcing is what burns contacts and couples into circuits causing erratic circuit behavior. 
The easy solution is to put a diode across the coil to allow the current to circulate until it dies.  The diode direction is opposite to activation current.  This will cause a delay in the the relay releasing.  Using a zener instead of a diode will shorten the delay.  There are proprietary relay suppressors for critical timing applications like the homing of stepping switches, specific to the relay models.  (I'm showing my age).

If you have put a capacitor across the relay coil to suppress the kickback, then that capacitor will certainly cause a current surge when your reed switch closes and will burn its contacts.  In that case a series resistor will reduce the surge current on contact.  Upon the contact opening, the capacitor and coil inductance will cause a ringing at their resonant frequency, whose amplitude may still be high enough to damage contacts.  Poke around with a high speed storage scope - you might be amazed at what you see.  CAUTION do not blow your scope with 10,000 volt spikes.   Contact bounce waveforms can give an indication of contact health.

User Rank
Re: That is OK, but there is a better way!
Amclaussen   12/6/2013 6:10:56 PM
Good answer, Electron Wrangler!...

But I like the Zener plus std. diode more: Using a Zener with an standard diode, back to back. That is the best recommendation I've tried, and was taken from an excellent Application Note published by Tyco Electronics Corp. (document 13C3264, Printed U.S.A., IH/12-00)

It says: "The Zener voltage value is chosen to limit the coil switch voltage to a level acceptable to the switch rating. This affords the best compromise both to coil switch protection and relay switching performance, and should be employed to assure maximum relay performance and reliability while providing protection to the control circuit from coil induced voltages."

While too many websites just repeat and repeat the single reverse diode across the coil approach as the one to use, the Tyco recommendation is the correct, inexpensive, easy one.  In my most recentapplication, I had to add a more robust relay to a radiator fan circuit using 12VDC in one of my modified cars, where I was replacing the original radiator with a larger one that has two electric fans, therefore I decided to use a beefier relay, which has a larger coil. So, I preferred to play it safe and was ready to use a simple diode across the relay's coil terminals, but happily found that application note at last minute. I became curious and tested both arrangements, plus other ones using diverse values of resistors. (some automotive relays even include small size resistors inside, placed across the coil). A trip to an electronic parts store (similar to a 'Rat-Shack') provided me with the parts on saturday's night, and the car was ready to run (quite literally) next morning!.

As the application note from Tyco stated, their fix was the very best, and that's why I'm telling all my friends about it!. Amclaussen.

User Rank
Cable Capacitance? AC relay coil in-rush?
tmoreau   11/22/2013 5:07:33 PM
Nobody mentions that the reed switch and relay might potentially be located very far apart for each other; and thus connected by a cable, which if very long then it could be a source of considerable capacitance.  The fact the the series 100 ohms worked, suggests it's not related to any lack of relay coil transient suppresion, but indeed due to in-rush current upon reed switch closure.  If the in-rush is not from the relay coil (magnetizing current), which I'm having a hard time seeing how that's possible if the coil current isn't reversing (we are not told if it's an AC or DC circuit); then another possible source of high in-rush current is cable capacitance.

I suspect the reed switch is being operated at line voltage AC, because 100 ohms is a rather large amount of resitance to be putting in series with any common 12/14VDC relay coil, and have the circuit still operate.  There is potentially some in-rush current associated with the coil of a true AC relay (by true AC relay I mean an armature made from iron laminations, not a relay made by using diodes in conjunction with a solid iron armature constructed exactly like a dc relay).  In-rush current from inductive ac equipment has to due with magnetization, which is at it's worst if you opened the circuit at the peak current of the ac cycle, then close the circuit at the reverse polarity peak in the ac cycle.



User Rank
The Best Fix
Critic   11/22/2013 4:58:53 PM
Adding a series resistor will certainly limit the current, which helps prevent damage to the reed switch in two ways:

1. With an inductive load, lower di/dt means lower induced voltage, hence reduced or eliminated contact arcing

2. Limted current reduces contact heating

However, adding a series resistor also limits the current capability of the switch at a given voltage.

The type of contact protection that should be used depends on the nature of the current:  dc or ac.  If we assume an inductive load (typical of relays), for dc, a diode across the relay coil to effectively short-circuit induced voltage (but not forward voltage used to energize the coil) works well, without the need to limit current using a resistor.  For ac, a properly-designed series RC circuit (snubber) in parallel with the reed switch reduces high-frequency high voltages across the contacts, but has negligible effect at the fundamental frequency.

Page 1/3  >  >>

Partner Zone
Latest Analysis
Released on September 19, 2014, this 5.5 inch screen iPhone is the larger version of the iPhone 6, whose teardown follows tomorrow.
A Design News course on field programmable gate arrays (FPGAs) should help engineers who are considering the technology for their upcoming designs.
In many engineering workplaces, there’s a generational conflict between recent engineering graduates and older, more experienced engineers. However, a recent study published in the psychology journal Cognition suggests that both may have something to learn from another group: 4 year olds.
CTC releases EtherCAT Master module for high-performance control of networked servos, stepping motors, and I/O devices.
Conventional wisdom holds that MIT, Cal Tech, and Stanford are three of the country’s best undergraduate engineering schools. Unfortunately, when conventional wisdom visits the topic of best engineering schools, it too often leaves out some of the most distinguished programs that don’t happen to offer PhD-level degrees.
Design News Webinar Series
9/10/2014 11:00 a.m. California / 2:00 p.m. New York
7/23/2014 11:00 a.m. California / 2:00 p.m. New York
7/17/2014 11:00 a.m. California / 2:00 p.m. New York
9/25/2014 11:00 a.m. California / 2:00 p.m. New York
Quick Poll
The Continuing Education Center offers engineers an entirely new way to get the education they need to formulate next-generation solutions.
Sep 22 - 26, MCU Software Development – A Step-by-Step Guide (Using a Real Eval Board)
SEMESTERS: 1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |  5  |  6

Focus on Fundamentals consists of 45-minute on-line classes that cover a host of technologies. You learn without leaving the comfort of your desk. All classes are taught by subject-matter experts and all are archived. So if you can't attend live, attend at your convenience.
Next Class: September 30 - October 2
Sponsored by Altera
Learn More   |   Login   |   Archived Classes
Twitter Feed
Design News Twitter Feed
Like Us on Facebook

Sponsored Content

Technology Marketplace

Copyright © 2014 UBM Canon, A UBM company, All rights reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service