Page 1/3  >  >>
User Rank
CAE tools would help too
naperlou   6/13/2013 9:47:19 AM
Frank, that is an interesting and very good analysis.  Your obvious deep knowledge makes it "easy" for you to see the situation.  On the other hand, not everyone has such a deep understanding.  It might have been useful for the designer to model the system in a CAE tool that can handle multiphysics.  The interaction of electrical and thermal effects is very important in electronics, and as you found out, often overlooked.

User Rank
Some Design Insight
rpercifield   6/13/2013 2:13:28 PM
The design process for a switching power supply design does take temps and ripple current into account for the derating of the capacitor. The various switcher controller manufacturers have simulation and design automation software services available to make a design very effective even for a novice.


In my experience most all output filtering capacitor failures are one of two issues. Problem one and the most prevalent is poor capacitor performance due to electrolyte formulation, or counterfeit components. In one issue we had a supplier that attempted to replicate the Panasonic electrolyte with disastrous results. Not one of their capacitors met the lifetime rating listed in the datasheet. The parts were failing at 1/10 of the rating on the sheet. Needless to say this was a big issue costing the company a significant amount of money.


The second issue is that the environment experienced is not what it was designed for. We have had units placed in very high temp ambients, far greater than the posted ratings. A rule of thumb is that every 10C increase in temp results in a reduction in life by 1/2. Given that you bought the unit used, you cannot rule out if it was placed in a high temp environment.


Switching power supply design is a very mature specialty, which can be fraught with pitfalls just like any other activity. While bad designs are out there, sometimes the explanation is much more simple than the derating choices made by the engineer.

Orin Laney
User Rank
single output diode = flyback
Orin Laney   6/14/2013 8:36:45 AM
The use of a single diode past the switching stage points to a flyback design.  If that is indeed the case, full wave rectification is not an applicable concept, and the assumpton that the charge/discharge current in the capacitor has a 50% duty cycle would not be correct except at a specific (and low) input voltage.  Flyback designs work well and are quire common, but they do need a decent HF rated output capacitor.

Frank in North Bergen
User Rank
what were the values of capacitor
Frank in North Bergen   6/14/2013 8:47:45 AM
Very good theory explaination of the bulging capacitor.

What was the original value capacitance of capacitor found in the original design? What value was it correctly replaced to?




Frank Karkota
User Rank
Frank Karkota   6/14/2013 11:04:44 AM
A few comments to responses.

Yes, there are capacitors that are designed for switching power supplies that have long life, but unfortunately Chinese makers of consumer products usually put in the cheapest part they can find.  Panasonic has a full line of electrolytics for every application, but they are expensive.  Most failure of consumer products are because of faulty aluminum electrolytic capacitors.  It is the duty of the designer, unfortunately, to assume that cheap or couterfeit parts will be used.  Even if the the designer approves the prototypes, the capacitors can be changed or substituted for counterfeits in production.

This power supply was not a flyback.  It was used for isolation from the power line and had a two-winding transformer.  I understand the compromises of using a full wave rectifier in that it takes a center-tapped winding or four diodes.  You are correct that a flyback cannot use a full wave bridge and they usually spec low ESR capacitors for best efficientcy.  

I do not remember the value, but I think that it was 1000 uf.  I replaced it with a Panasonic capacitor or the same value.  The replacement capacitor was intended for power supply use.

User Rank
The complex issue
RBedell   6/14/2013 1:21:04 PM
Mr. Karkota states what I have thought to be obvious.  But as Naperlou, observes, that may not be true.  To the considerations of pathologies of failure, let me add a few of my theories.  The transformer output from a switching supply is more 'square' than the output of a linear transformer (translation: it has faster rise times).  These faster rise times translates to higher surging charge currents.  The inverse it also true; the faster fall times translates to higher surging discharge currents.  The ESR plus higher surge currents equals heat; as Mr. Karkota states.  But, the inductive component of the electrolytic capacitor plays a larger part as the frequency goes up.  While there are electrolytic caps specified with a low-ESR, few if any are spec'ed with a low-ESL (effective series inductance).  This ESL would cause uneven charge distribution down the length of foil in relation to the charge-discharge(C-D) frequency.  All other things being equal, the amount of capacitance 'seen' by the circuit will diminish with increase in frequency. 

To solve this problem; If 3000uF was needed for filtering on a switching supply; should one use a single 3000uF cap or three 1000uF caps?  The 1000uF's are the better option because the C-D currents would be distributed across the three caps.  A lower current is lower heat produced.

Additionally, derating the capacitance in relation to heat is obvious; but what about derating the cap voltage and  'uprating' the ESR?

Then there is how components are packed into smaller spaces creating higher temp operating environments.

William K.
User Rank
The Power supply as an afterthought?
William K.   6/15/2013 3:02:53 PM
It is often amazing that some piece of equipment, while having some specialized part of the circuit be well thought out and a good design, will then have a power supply that looks like it was dsigned in a real hurry by an inexperienced individual, or possibly designed by an accountant. And so under rated parts are tightly packed in an area with inadequate ventillation. And so the power supply fails while the balance of the system is OK. 

But good detective work on the fix.

User Rank
Power supplies
SSLGuru   6/19/2013 3:44:14 PM
Great piece - thanks. The multi-discpline detail is what makes electronic product development so much fun... and so painfull.

 It struck me that were this a cable television or other set top box in the USA today you probably would not have been able to fix things quite so rapidly. (Guessing this applies in other continents too now). The Energy Star standard would make that front end voltage down-conversion somewhat less accessible visually. A bad design could still show bulging caps of course.

Also, the pesky unwanted noise emission issues arising from the new tighter energy standard today would likley mean that a senior engineer would have had to think perhaps just a tad more about the front end supply design these days. More thought... more components and of course all the more opportunity to accidetally screw things up.

 Chances are you could still see a big fat non-SMT cap in that same position though.


Thanks again,

Jon Connell, Brooklyn, NY

User Rank
Old man river
Noswad   6/19/2013 3:46:41 PM
Nothing will last forever. I am sure a designer can design a product to last for 50 years but the end cost for the consumer would be very high. We are used to paying cheap prices for stuff these days, even though we know it will only last a couple of years.

It has to do more with economics instead of engineering.

William K.
User Rank
Re: The complex issue
William K.   6/19/2013 5:37:16 PM
RBedell, are you any relation to a Dwight Bedell who lived in Royal Oak back on the 1950s? He was an amatueur radio operator.

Page 1/3  >  >>

Partner Zone
Latest Analysis
The term “autopilot” is now at the heart of a growing debate between Tesla Motors Inc. and Germany’s Federal Motor Transport Authority.
A make-your-own Star Wars Sith Lightsaber hilt is heftier and better-looking than most others out there, according to its maker, Sean Charlesworth. You can 3D print it from free source files, and there's even a hardware kit available -- not free -- so you can build one just in time for Halloween.
Highly regarded engineer and physicist Ransom Stephens speaks with Design News about his extensive science and engineering background, the serious yet funny study of neuroscience, and how one primes their brain for innovation.
It's your turn to cast your vote for one of these 12 finalists to win the ARM TechCon Reader's Choice Award for the most innovative product of the past year.
While supercapacitors and rechargeable Lithium-ion batteries both store energy, these two technologies are very different in their design and in their performance capabilities.
Quick Poll
The Continuing Education Center offers engineers an entirely new way to get the education they need to formulate next-generation solutions.
Oct 10 - 14, Embedded System Design Techniques™: Getting Started Developing Professional Embedded Software
SEMESTERS: 1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |  5  |  6 |  7 | 8 | 9 | 10

Focus on Fundamentals consists of 45-minute on-line classes that cover a host of technologies. You learn without leaving the comfort of your desk. All classes are taught by subject-matter experts and all are archived. So if you can't attend live, attend at your convenience.
Next Course September 27-29:
Sponsored by 3M
Learn More   |   Login   |   Archived Classes
Twitter Feed
Design News Twitter Feed
Like Us on Facebook

Technology Marketplace

Copyright © 2016 UBM Canon, A UBM company, All rights reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service