Maytag is not the only company to cut a corner on squirrl cage blower designs. Our whirlpool dryer, and the one belonging to a friend, also developed the rubbing blower syndrome, but the fix was not that easy. It seems that the main blower is only connected to the drive shaft by a rather weak spring clamp, with no means of positive attachment. But the blower is not perfectly balanced, and not immune to the accumulation of a bit of lint, since it is downstream from the drying clothes. What happens is that the blower wheel vibrates just a bit on the shaft, which the atachment is a split hub made of the same nylon-type of material. The result is that there is wear, resulting in greater clearance, resulting in greater vibration. Eventually the wear will reach the point that the blower wheel no longer engages the shaft, and so it does not spin, resultingin no airflow, which leads to an overheating condition, which causes the non-resettable overtemperature device to open, leaving the system non-functional. The only repair is replacing the blower wheel and the overtemp protection device, which are accessed from opposite acess points on the dryer. But that does not eliminate the problem with the drive connecton to the blower wheel, which the replacement is not improved from the original design. The (sort of) fix is adding a screw type hose clamp in place of the weaker spring clamp, although a real fix would be a solid hub, close fitting, and a different design to keep it on the shaft, such as a bolt in the end of the shaft and a cup-washer to clamp the hub. BUT of course that would mean changing the design and adding a production step or two. Better quality does cost more to build, it seems.
Not qute designed to fail but it sure is hard to not be paranoid about the failure to tell the user that there was a filter that had to be serviced periodically so some repair person could charge an outrageous sum for a trivial service operation.
That is an evil monkey at work not a dumb monkey like the second issue with the blower.
Not letting folks know about the filter changing requirement is the one way that they have of keeping those totally unqualified fingers out. And there are a lot of folks so inept that they cross-thread lightbulbs. Of course, some companies go way overboard, like the five-point anti-tamper screws on a seagate external hard drive. They were a pain to remove, but I did remove them and replaced the failed hard drive. Possibly some of it comes from a desire to avoid litigation for somebody injuring themselves, inept people do that a lot.
But on that dishwasher, the well designed ones use a different system to avoid the need for filter cleaning. And some of the other good ones make the filter easy to find. That may be part of the difference between an older expensive unit and a current cheap one.
True enuf about keeping inept people from hurting themselves but how about at least warning to the owner that the filter needs to be serviced periodically. That monkey mind set is not a good way to build customer satisfaction and loyalty.
Adding a small boss on the end of a molded nylon squirrel cage rotor is not a very expensive thing to do. The material cost is close to zero and the cost to machine the recess in the mold is divided by 50,000+ parts.
What it really boils down to is the mindset of the company management and their focus on quarterly earnings instead of long term sales based on a quality product. I have, unfortunately, seen it at several companies that I have either worked for or done consulting work for.
I agree Cabe, but as big box appliances add more electronics, they seem to lose dependability. Time after time, our Monkey writers regret having given up their mechanical washers, dishwashers and dryers.
Larry M, the spring clamp is the source of the problem, since the spring allows movement, which causes the wear. And at 1750 RPM the small unbalance of the worm style clamp is not a big deal. But if it were, it would be a simple matter to use two of them so as to maintain balance.
I had a dishwasher that somehow had the drain age flow clean the food filter, so that the filter did not normally need to be manually cleaned. If a dishwasher manual indicated that dishes had to be cleaned prior to washing, I would consider that a deffective design and retuyrn the machine and demand a refund. A machine that is unable to do the job that it is made for is JUNK.
Larry, all of those clamps are spring clamps, and besides that they all apply the clamping force along a single line, at least the wire ones do. The third link shows a clamp similar to what is provided with the blower wheel, and that one does allow the very slight motion that causes the wear. The worm gear style clamps don't have any compliance, they wind up being rigid, and so allow no motion. The whole problem is that there is a very small movement that leads to wear, which loosens the joint, leading to more motion and more wear.
In addition, a spring wire clamp that was tight enough to prevent all relative motion would probably exceed the allowable surface loading of the material.
I have written several times about this very problem. I have a Kenmore washer, with no mention of a filter, and Kenmore freezer with no mention of a backup 9v battery. I had a Bowlens electric lawnmower with no mention of a design feature that would trap grass and cause the motor to overheat. Not only was there no mention of this problem, there was no nondestructive way to clean it out. The lawnmower problem was discovered when I did a teardown on the machine. The Kenmore problems were solved by doing research on the internet and finding information from other owners who shared their stories.
I am only defending the filter design and not the bearing issue!
I have had a maytag dishwasher (and other brands) and most all of them suggest rinsing the dishes prior to loading into the machine. But, I just load them into the dishwasher with all the clumps of food stuff, ketchup piles, and corn kernels still on the plates. I even throw in the mashed potato spoon still full of junk! Knowing this, the manufactures have to filter the pump (which is usually a screen on the floor of the unit). But even this can suck those mashed potatos into the system. One thing that seems to be constant is the wash arms are two piece designs glued together. Thus, the better manufactures make sure to filter this part to prevent the holes from clogging up. The Whirlpool dishwasher I currently have does not and the wash arms got plugged up. To fix them I had to purchase new ones. Now I take them out about every 6 months and thourghly clean them out!
So (and this is only a guess on my part) I think Maytag may actually have been trying to prevent the spray arms from clogging up. But why they do not mention this filter in the manual is monkey material!
I too have a dishwasher (10 years old) the slowly got worse in cleaning the dishes. I tracked it down to the last hole in the lower swing arm being clogged (both ends). This last hole was angled so it would push the swing arm around to clean most every part of the compartment.
I ended up finding the smallest tweezers I could to reach in to the hole and pull out the food that was stuck inside. I do that every few months to keep the unit cleaning fairly well. It is down stream of the filter (and that is clean) but small parts accumulate at the end of the arm, probably from centrifugal force. Once it cakes up the arm just stays in on e spot for the whole cycle.
I suspect the filter plugging on a 19 year old dish washer is due to the environmental changes made in dishwasher detergent, and not a monkey at Maytag. The detergents are now all phosphate free, thanks to a few States implementing regulations a few years ago. It fits the timing well. The problem with the new detergents is that a film forms that won't wash off many surfaces of your dishwasher. That probably plugged the filter. Before that the filter would have flushed clean every time the washer drained. Now you have to run some TSP through the washer, or buy one of the special dishwasher cleaning solutions being sold by the same detergent companies. Does anyone else see the irony of having to run a special wash solution through a washer to keep it clean?
Transfers the control of a large number of motion axes from one numerical control kernel to another within a CNC system, using multiple NCKs, and enables implement control schemes for virtually any type of machine tool.
Focus on Fundamentals consists of 45-minute on-line classes that cover a host of technologies. You learn without leaving the comfort of your desk. All classes are taught by subject-matter experts and all are archived. So if you can't attend live, attend at your convenience.