User Rank
GlennA   6/20/2012 8:43:31 AM
An unloading valve is not the same as a relief valve or a regulating valve.  From my training:  An unloading valve is used to direct all flow from the pump to the tank at low pressure to reduce heating, and to allow the electric motor / pump to start under no-load.  A relief valve is used to control maximum system pressure.  When the maximum pressure is reached, the valve opens to direct flow to the tank without reducing the pressure.  A pressure reducing valve, also called a regulating valve, is used to reduce pressure to a segment of the system.  Not everyone that works in hydraulics agrees with the nomenclature that I learned.

Instead of a variable speed motor, I have seen pressure and flow compensating pumps that have a swash plate that is adjusted to reduce the flow from the pump without affecting the pressure, at a constant electric motor speed.

User Rank
Re: hydraulics vs working applications
crob09   6/19/2012 4:44:37 PM
No you still need an "unloading valve" or Bypass valve, no different from an electric forklift. The PTO is variable speed and the unloading valve is still necessary when the load is too great, or if the cylinder has reached it's maximum travel. Otherwise you would burn out the PTO or motor.



User Rank
Re: hydraulics vs working applications
Alex.W   6/19/2012 1:51:55 PM
I think the variable speed drive would negate the need for an unloading valve, assuming there were no other loads requiring driving while this subset of the machine is in standby.

TJ McDermott
User Rank
Each has its place
TJ McDermott   6/18/2012 1:57:58 PM
Hydraulic vs. Electric is not a winner-take-all competition.  Each has roles in which it is better suited.  One of my customers offers products that use either one or the other as the prime mover, depending on application.  It means more engineering work for my customer, but their end users are happy with a solution that fits their needs, rather than adjusting their needs to fit a single solution.


User Rank
hydraulics vs working applications
GlennA   6/18/2012 9:34:11 AM
Hydraulic robots have become few and far between (in my experience).  The rationale that I was told was because of the automotive industry.  Automotive is a big user of robots.  When robots were hydraulic, 3 (sometimes 4) trades were required to work on them.  The electrician for the controller, the millwright for the hardware, or for tooling issues (sometimes a tool-maker also), and a plumber for the hydraulics.  The all-electric robot eliminated one trade from that group.

The manipulator arm on the Space Shuttle was a 'hydraulic' application = high torque and low speed.  Clean-room issues i.e. hydraulic oil leaks would have been a problem.  A broken wire does not 'leak' electricity in the same way a broken hose would leak oil.

One thing that I think is missing from your hydraulic system is the unloading valve.  Many of the machines that I have worked on had an unloading valve to direct flow to the tank at low pressure to reduce heating when the system was in standby.

Partner Zone
Latest Analysis
The term “autopilot” is now at the heart of a growing debate between Tesla Motors Inc. and Germany’s Federal Motor Transport Authority.
A make-your-own Star Wars Sith Lightsaber hilt is heftier and better-looking than most others out there, according to its maker, Sean Charlesworth. You can 3D print it from free source files, and there's even a hardware kit available -- not free -- so you can build one just in time for Halloween.
Highly regarded engineer and physicist Ransom Stephens speaks with Design News about his extensive science and engineering background, the serious yet funny study of neuroscience, and how one primes their brain for innovation.
It's your turn to cast your vote for one of these 12 finalists to win the ARM TechCon Reader's Choice Award for the most innovative product of the past year.
While supercapacitors and rechargeable Lithium-ion batteries both store energy, these two technologies are very different in their design and in their performance capabilities.
Quick Poll
The Continuing Education Center offers engineers an entirely new way to get the education they need to formulate next-generation solutions.
Oct 10 - 14, Embedded System Design Techniques™: Getting Started Developing Professional Embedded Software
SEMESTERS: 1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |  5  |  6 |  7 | 8 | 9 | 10

Focus on Fundamentals consists of 45-minute on-line classes that cover a host of technologies. You learn without leaving the comfort of your desk. All classes are taught by subject-matter experts and all are archived. So if you can't attend live, attend at your convenience.
Next Course September 27-29:
Sponsored by 3M
Learn More   |   Login   |   Archived Classes
Twitter Feed
Design News Twitter Feed
Like Us on Facebook

Technology Marketplace

Copyright © 2016 UBM Canon, A UBM company, All rights reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service