I agree with you, tekochip. Although there was a fair amount of media coverage when the Secretary of Transportation made his pronouncement, it paled by comparison to the amount of coverage the story got when it orginally broke.
Lighten up, "cookiejar." Your indignation about this matter is very selective. On one hand you refer to the "industry friendly mandarins of NHTSA and NASA." On the other, you cite a NASA pdf file to make your point about tin whiskers. The fact is, NHTSA's final report cited tin whiskers on pages 46, 48, 69 and 74 (those are the pdf page numbers), proving that it was aware of the issue. In the end, though, the report concluded that the tin whisker effect is not dangerous. Its conclusion was that it would have been impossible for tin whiskers to cause the Toyota vehicles to accelerate out of control. As I noted in the story, the Secretary of Transportation emphatically stated that the verdict was in: "There's no electronic-based cause for unintended high-speed acceleration in Toyotas. Period," he said. For this story, we also talked to the Center for Automotive Research and Consumer Reports. Reports by the National Academy of Sciences and by Edmunds.com have reached similar conclusions. If you can demonstrate that tin whiskers were the cause, I strongly suggest you call Edmunds, which offered a prize of $1 million to anyone who could demonstrate "a novel cause for unintended acceleration." If all these people are in on some kind of conspiracy, it must be a whopper.
To see NHTSA's final report, go to the following page and click on the link that says "NHTSA Full Report":
I wish to express my outrage at the lies contained in this report!
In its investigation NASA found examples of throttle sensors that had grown Tin wiskers that shorted out the pot's leads effectively indicating a full throttle command. The web link to the NASA paper is here: http://nepp.nasa.gov/whisker/reference/tech_papers/2011-NASA-GSFC-whisker-failure-app-sensor.pdf
This is an example of an undesirable side effect typical of every human endeavor. In this case the desire to eliminate lead from solder has resulted in a proliferation of tin wiskers causing no end of trouble in electronic circuitry.
I would question the use of carbon potentiometers for this critical throttle control application. D.C. voltage applied to a carbon pot makes it go noisy rather quickly . I'm not aware of a single carbon volume control pot, which by the way is normally only subject to A.C., that I've owned that hasn't got noisy within 10 years of use. We're talking about blow your speakers type noisy.
In one report on the Audi runaway problem, the engineer was able to readily reproduce the runaway problem caused by alternator noise wreaking havoc with the controller CPU when the battery's impedance rose at high temperature extremes.
It's obvious to me that both of your mentioned reports were written by the industry friendly mandarins of NHTSA and NASA. These do a major disservice to the hard work of some honest engineers, who take due diligence seriously, especially when people's lives are at risk.
bdcst; Some vehicles have 'hill start assist' that maintains braking for a short time to allow time to press the accelerator. Rolling backward was more of an issue when the clutch pedal was also present. Some drivers have the (bad habit) of 'two-foot' driving; one foot on the accelerator and one foot on the brake; poor mileage, poor acceleration, brake pads wear out quickly, the driver following can't tell riding the brake pedal from actual braking.
Yes but..good driving skills may include keeping the brake pedal depressed while giving the vehicle some gas when starting up on a steep hill so it won't roll backwards. Thus, the interlock firmware needs to be intelligent and not override the throttle the instant both both pedals are activated.
It seems somewhat unfair that Toyota's acceleration problem got so much press when it was first examined, but when the cause was not found to be a software or electrical issue the media was mute. If the driver doesn't panic there are plenty of methods to disengage power by shifting into neutral or turning the car off. Adding this additional method to cut power in drive by wire systems wouldn't add any additional hardware, and would remove power even if the driver panics.
A middle school team from Rochester, Mich., has again nabbed the grand prize in the annual international Future City Competition, which drew students from 37 regions of the United States, as well as from England and China.
The word “smart” is becoming the dumbest word around. It has been applied to almost every device and system in our homes. In addition to smartphones and smart meters, we now hear about smart clothing and smart shoes, smart lights, smart homes, smart buildings, and every trendy city today has its smart city project. Just because it has a computer inside and is connected to the Web, does not mean it is smart.
Are you being paid enough? Do you want a better job? According to a recent survey Manpower released just before Engineers Week, employers and engineers don't see eye-to-eye about the state of US engineers' skills and experience.
Focus on Fundamentals consists of 45-minute on-line classes that cover a host of technologies. You learn without leaving the comfort of your desk. All classes are taught by subject-matter experts and all are archived. So if you can't attend live, attend at your convenience.