No matter where I've lived--in the middle of Los Angeles or a nice suburban town in Northern California--no one pays any attention to car alarms. I would think that's even truer, if that's possible, in NY. I agree about the possible law, and have been amazed such a one has never passed, even here in litigious California.
Your example of a car alarm is a good one, in that the false alarm rate is so high that these alarms are essentially ignored. Indeed, there can and should be a law that that audible alarm portion of car alarms have to be disabled. The siren serves no purpose. The function of a car alarm is to disable the capability of starting the car. That's how it prevents theft, not by warbling so that some samaritan will come by and smite the potential car thief. I live in NY, and if your car alarm goes off, your automobile is on its own, buddy. Nobody's gonna come by and tell anyone to step away from the vehicle..
I haven't been in hotels with false alarms in the middle of the night--that must be terrifying!--but I sure do remember the MGM Grand fire. It's made me nervous about staying in multi-story hotels ever since. I agree, a high rate of false alarms makes us tend to ignore them. Just think about car alarms! The universal signal to ignore an alarm, and a good example of the cry wolf phenomenon (for those who grew up reading fairy tales).
In my grade school, we had fire drills religiously where we marched outside and lined up in our appropriate class lines and waited for the all clear from our school safety officer. That was until we had an actual fire in the school. At this point, the alarm did not go off. Instead the principal called all people on the PA system and told everyone stay in their class rooms until the smoke had cleared. I to this day do not know the rationale of this decision, nor do I know why we did not follow the drill. I guess some plans are only plans until there is an actual problem.
I agree, Tool_maker. I am always amazed at the patience and dogged pursuit of the problems by so many of the contributors in the Sherlock Ohms story. This is a classic example, performed in a very important setting.
This may seem like an insignificant and tangential comment, but apropos of false alarms I just realized that I've been in many hotel situations in the past several years where an earsplitting alarm went off in the middle of the night, you get up worried and don't know what to do, often opening the door a bit in your underwear to find out what's up, and then the alarm shuts off and end of story. No fire, no explanation. This is dangerous because it trains you to ignore hotel fire alarms, so when the real one comes one day, you're gonna be in trouble. This is not trivial. Remember the MGM Grand fire in Las Vegas in 1980? False alarms are a dangerous design flaw. More properly, there will always be false alarms (if you stanch them completely you will miss some real situations). The problem is when you have too high a false alarm rate.
@Ralphy Boy: Your last sentence is true in every line of work. Whether it is a safety system in a power plant, the ignition system in your car or an irregular heartbeat, being able to replicate the problem so one knows what to repair is a gift from God. Either that or dumb luck.
I periodically visited nuclear plants as part of my job in the late '70s and never heard, nor heard of, a siren going off outside. I agree with you, Alex, this is not a small issue. It's scary to think that the problem became evident in retrospect, rather than being prevented in the first place.
Earlier this year paralyzed IndyCar drive Sam Schmidt did the seemingly impossible -- opening the qualifying rounds at Indy by driving a modified Corvette C7 Stingray around the Indianapolis Motor Speedway.
Wearables are changing the way we see ourselves. With onboard sensors that have access to our bodies, we are starting to know our physical selves like never before, quantifying our activity, our heart rate, breathing, and even our muscle effort.
Last week, the bill for reforming chemical regulation, the TSCA Modernization Act of 2015, passed the House. If it or a similar bill becomes law, the effects on cost and availability of adhesives and plastics incorporating these substances are not yet clear.
This year, Design News is getting a head start on the Fourth of July celebration. In honor of our country and its legacy of engineering innovation -- in all of its forms -- we are taking you on an alphabetical tour through all 50 states to showcase interesting engineering breakthroughs and historically significant events.
Focus on Fundamentals consists of 45-minute on-line classes that cover a host of technologies. You learn without leaving the comfort of your desk. All classes are taught by subject-matter experts and all are archived. So if you can't attend live, attend at your convenience.