Despite the steady stream of mobile design apps announced and shipped over these last few months, a lot of Design News readers remain unconvinced that any CAD or design tool worth its salt can translate optimally to a mobile platform.
Security remains a concern for engineers, who have serious doubts about sending their prized design intellectual property back and forth over the Internet, despite vendor assurances that Web-based services can be just as secure (if not more secure, in some cases) than corporate networks locked down with VPNs and firewalls. The still-limited horsepower of smartphones and tablets for processing heavy-duty graphics like 3D CAD files compared to supercharged engineering workstations is another longstanding hurdle, as are concerns about the limited real estate for viewing complex geometry and assemblies.
eDrawings supports the multitouch gesture features of the iPad, allowing users to pan, zoom, and rotate models easily. (Source: SolidWorks)
All these concerns (some justified and some not, in my opinion) are hardly stopping leading CAD and design tool vendors from pulling out the stops and rolling out new offerings. SolidWorks is the latest to jump on the bandwagon with the release of an iPad version of eDrawings, its collaboration tool that lets users share 2D and 3D files.
eDrawings lets anyone involved in product development (not just CAD users) load and send 2D and 3D designs via email. The viewing tool essentially creates a lightweight representation of 3D models or 2D drawings created by SolidWorks and other widely used CAD systems, opening the door for anyone with a PC to examine and provide input on design data. With the iPad version, anyone with that device can view, interpret, and peruse the design data, making it a viable option at client sites, in the field at a sales meeting, or at home.
The iPad edition of eDrawings leverages Tech Soft 3D's HOOPS Visualize platform to power its graphics with advanced file compression, real-time collaboration, and 2D, 3D, text, and hard copy capabilities. It has also been fully tuned to support the multi-touch gesture features of the iPad, so users can pan, zoom, and rotate models easily. This version supports the viewing of DWG and DXF files.
SolidWorks is hardly the only player offering 3D file viewing on tablets. We reported previously on the Autodesk Design Review Mobile app for Apple iOS and Android, as well as IMSI/Design's TurboViewer app, which is available in both free and professional $9.99 versions. In fact, some in the blogosphere were chiding SolidWorks, not just for being slightly behind in terms of releasing a mobile version of eDrawings, but also for initially supporting only the iPad, as opposed to Android tablets.
Critics say Android tablets offer more real estate than Apple offerings, thus providing a more effective platform for visualizing robust graphics. SolidWorks, among other developers, typically targets Apple iOS for initial mobile app deliverables because there is one API, compared with multiple APIs for the Android platform, thus making the development effort far less complex.
TJ I'm surprised too that there is a fee. Most companies are really good at figuring out how to give the masses a little taste of something free and recovering from another angle. While I like my iPad, I would prefer the pc version.
@TJ: Security concerns will also be an issue with cloud-based applications and services, but the truth is the security protections are evolving and certainly not stopping the transition across all industries and applications to a Web-based delivery model. I think companies will start using the mobile design tool technology with IP that is less critical. I mean most companies employ outside suppliers and design partners, with which they are sharing CAD files and opening up IP. This is really just a different method for doing so.
That phrase, Beth, more than any other, would make me pause for ANY sort of cloud based solution.
The Black Hat security conference held each year has contests to see what it takes to break into "secure" systems. The results are such that I would not trust any vendor's assurances.
I was going to write "If it's connected to the internet, it's not secure". However, that implies the correllary, that "Anything not connected to the internet IS secure". We now know even that is not true. Well, at least Iran's nuclear program knows that; the Stuxnet virus designed to impair that project was apparently carried in on flash drives.
Stating security equal to that of corporate VPNs and firewalls just doesn't fly.
How many readers were affected by Linked-In's security breach? Affected can mean simply having to change your password.
Putting your data out there to make it easy to access has a risk. If it's out there for you, it's out there to be had by nefarious types.
The Stuxnet penetration of the Iranian nuclear program was brilliant; it's the stuff of Hollywood movies (Sneakers comes to mind), and yet it happened in real life.
Dozer, I'm surprised they're charging anything at all for the app. E-Drawings is a FREE download for your PC.
Solidworks keeps it inexpensive because they get your money when you purchase the 3D modeler that creates the files in the first place. Solidworks, AutoDesk Inventor, and the like are NOT inexpensive.
I agree Nadine. It doesn't even need to be all that much - just the ability to change some text / dimensions or even annotate the drawing so you can make the real changes back in the office. Sort of like a number of PDF viewers have out there where you can add notes and mark-ups.
It's not surprising that security is a concern among readers -- that often seems to be the case with new Internet-based technologies, whether they're for consumers or professionals. If past performance is an indicator, though, the security concerns will shrink or disappear, and the apps will gain momentum.
How can they make money sellling it that cheap? Are they selling the app that cheap so that a lot of people will buy it? and do you just buy the app or do you just buy a subscription? Because if you buy the app if you had a jailbroken ipad you could get the app free but if it is only $2 it would hardly be worth your time.
I haven't heard anything about being able to update artwork on ipads yet. I may be out of the loop because I don't have an ipad.
I use Creative Suite more often than anything. Apple and Adobe said their feud ended last year but I'm still waiting to see real resutls. Being able to show a CAD in a meeting on an ipad and make minor changes in real time would be impressive. Something lighter and more portable than a laptop for meetings would be nice but it has to be more than a picture frame.
I am very excited about the upcoming Microsoft Surface(Pro version) with its I5 processor and 128 gig of storage. This could very well be a viable way to use an MCAD program like Alibre - something no iPad could even begin to do.
And at just 2 lbs with built-in keyboard and stylus support, traveling with some super-lightweight firepower will finally be possible.
The problem with writing apps for Android is that not all apps will work on all devices. I know of several apps that look fine on a phone, but get wonky when used on a tablet, and vice versa. That's the main reason I dropped my Android tablet and went to an iPad. It was nice and I could do some stuff on it, but I couldn't run everything I wanted to. I haven't had that problem with the iPad.
From Dell / Intel® New Paradigms in Design Work Scott Hamilton, vertical market strategist for Dell Precision workstations, 5/2/2013 5
Early in my career, I worked as a draftsman and remember the days of drawing on vellum with numbered pencils and Mylar with plastic lead. This was a fun experience in the sense that I ...
I've been using workstations for more than 10 years and love finding ways to get more performance from my system. With demanding professional applications that require more power each ...
A lasting memory from my first job as an engineer in an auto assembly plant is standing on hard concrete at six in the morning, vending-machine coffee clutched in hand, listening to ...
For industrial control applications, or even a simple assembly line, that machine can go almost 24/7 without a break. But what happens when the task is a little more complex? That’s where the “smart” machine would come in. The smart machine is one that has some simple (or complex in some cases) processing capability to be able to adapt to changing conditions. Such machines are suited for a host of applications, including automotive, aerospace, defense, medical, computers and electronics, telecommunications, consumer goods, and so on. This radio show will show what’s possible with smart machines, and what tradeoffs need to be made to implement such a solution.
To save this item to your list of favorite Design News content so you can find it later in your Profile page, click the "Save It" button next to the item.
If you found this interesting or useful, please use the links to the services below to share it with other readers. You will need a free account with each service to share an item via that service.
Tweet This
16 
