Not everyone involved in rapid manufacturing thinks additive fabrication systems will win over the hearts and minds of design engineers and manufacturers. Protomold President Brad Cleveland is placing his bets on what he calls "intelligent subtractive" manufacturing — or the use of interrelated design, CAM and operations software to streamline the many manufacturing steps that surround high-speed machining.
"We're banking on the combination of advancements in software algorithms, processing systems and off-the-shelf CNC machining technology over anything additive," says Cleveland, who earlier in his career actually co-founded a company that made additive metal components.
His reasoning partly involves speed. "We just believe that for the foreseeable future, it will be much faster to cut materials than to build up parts layer by layer," he says. And he isn't just boasting when he talks about speed. Protomold's high-speed machining operations have gotten so fast that the company can supply injection-molded parts in a single business day, which means it takes Protomold only a fraction of a day to machine aluminum mold cores and cavities. Protomold's sister company, First Cut Prototype, has similarly short lead times for machined plastic parts.
Another reason why Cleveland believes additive processes won't become much more prominent than they are today boils down to materials. "There are severe limitations in materials available for additive processes," he says. "And many of the materials are sole source. Tell that to your purchasing department." Moreover, he points to the deficiencies in the surface finish and strength properties of additive parts as factors that will weight against them in applications that truly require molded or machined properties.
For all his seeming pessimism about additive processes, Cleveland believes they will have a role in the future — just not a particularly large one. He acknowledges additive processes can excel at mass customization and produce part geometries that subtractive methods cannot. But these two advantages translate only to niche applications in his view. "For every part that is best made with an additive process I can show you 100 that are better made via intelligent subtractive processes," he says.
Strength Smackdown: Additive Fabrication Versus Molding and Machining
Protomold president Brad Cleveland believes that the mechanical properties of plastic parts made on additive machines don't come close enough to those of injection-molded and machined plastic parts, which creates design engineering difficulties. So Design News asked Cleveland to back up his assertions about material properties — and he did. Protomold hired an independent materials testing lab, Stork Materials Technology, to run ASTM tensile and flexural tests of three kinds of ABS parts — injection molded, CNC machined and fused deposition modeled (FDM) — on a Stratasys machine. The study tested the FDM part in different orientations to account for the anisotropy found in additive parts. It also tests the molded part in two different gating configurations. The study, whose results are summarized in these tables below and which can be downloaded in full here, shows a significant strength advantage for machined and molded ABS grades.
Gigabit and PoE are two networking technologies moving ahead in tandem as industrial users power remote Ethernet devices such as IP security cameras at 1,000 Mbps over existing CAT5 cable.
New disc magnet motors fit into the design trend of stepping up to closed loop performance while maintaining the cost advantage of stepper motor technology.
At the Design News webinar on June 27, learn all about aluminum extrusion: designing the right shape so it costs the least, is simplest to manufacture, and best fits the application's structural requirements.
A new battery design, which replaces lithium with abundant and low-cost elemental sulfur, is still in its nascent stages but shows real promise for giving batteries more energy potential.
From Dell / Intel® New Paradigms in Design Work Scott Hamilton, vertical market strategist for Dell Precision workstations, 5/2/2013 5
Early in my career, I worked as a draftsman and remember the days of drawing on vellum with numbered pencils and Mylar with plastic lead. This was a fun experience in the sense that I ...
I've been using workstations for more than 10 years and love finding ways to get more performance from my system. With demanding professional applications that require more power each ...
A lasting memory from my first job as an engineer in an auto assembly plant is standing on hard concrete at six in the morning, vending-machine coffee clutched in hand, listening to ...
For industrial control applications, or even a simple assembly line, that machine can go almost 24/7 without a break. But what happens when the task is a little more complex? That’s where the “smart” machine would come in. The smart machine is one that has some simple (or complex in some cases) processing capability to be able to adapt to changing conditions. Such machines are suited for a host of applications, including automotive, aerospace, defense, medical, computers and electronics, telecommunications, consumer goods, and so on. This radio show will show what’s possible with smart machines, and what tradeoffs need to be made to implement such a solution.
To save this item to your list of favorite Design News content so you can find it later in your Profile page, click the "Save It" button next to the item.
If you found this interesting or useful, please use the links to the services below to share it with other readers. You will need a free account with each service to share an item via that service.
Tweet This
2 
