Automotive News
Slideshow: Conservative Design Makes Japanese Cars More Reliable

Image 1 of 18      Next >

The Toyota RAV4 -- with four-cylinder and six-cylinder engines -- got high marks for used car reliability.(Source: Toyota)
The Toyota RAV4 -- with four-cylinder and six-cylinder engines -- got high marks for used car reliability.
(Source: Toyota)

Image 1 of 18      Next >

Return to Article

View Comments: Newest First|Oldest First|Threaded View
<<  <  Page 6/9  >  >>
Greg M. Jung
User Rank
Re: Still question article.
Greg M. Jung   4/5/2013 7:05:08 PM
@Bunter:  Good point about the variable valve timing innovation breakthrough.  The Japanese have been making innovative breakthroughs also (so maybe their reliability is due to other factors besids just incremental refinement).

I also remember the 4 wheel steering innovation on the Honda Prelude years ago (and don't recall any reliability issues on this innovative breakthrough).

User Rank
Re: Additional information
Constitution_man   4/5/2013 5:07:50 PM
CR has been enamored with Honda since the Garden of Eden.  Toyota is also infallible in their book.  CR wouldn't acknowledge a top German or American product if we bribed them to do so... um, wait a minute.... ! !

Charles Murray
User Rank
Re: better engineering = reliability.
Charles Murray   4/5/2013 4:22:29 PM
Good points, D Hambley. Yes, automakers think Americans want cheapness over quality. If you watch television commercials, they also seem to think Americans want virility over quality. Why else could we be getting so many models that are called the SX, EX, XS, XE --gee, what could they be getting at?

William K.
User Rank
Conservatrive design, or is it lack of innovation?
William K.   4/5/2013 4:21:53 PM
The car rating magazines seem to have been in love with those Jap cars nearly forever, and that makes me suspect that they are just a bit subjective in their evaluations. Besides that, conservative design includes copying what others have already developed after it is possible to see just what variations were most widely accepted. And someplace in there is the consideration of cars being easy to work on and having aftermarket service parts available. And the Jap brands have been quite diligent about changing parts just a bit every year so that the aftermarket folks would have a hard time producing replacement parts. Not everybody notices that, but I certainly do. 

So you cn go around telling everyone that your favorite brand is so very much "better" than others and if you say it often enough and with enough authoratative tone, a lot of folks can wind up believing you. And if you copy the good ideas of others after they are fully developed you have not only avoided the risk of something new, but also avoided the costs of developing something new. This leads to greater profits with less effort, doesn't it?

Charles Murray
User Rank
Re: Reliability, Quality and Staying in Business
Charles Murray   4/5/2013 4:13:30 PM
Yes, Mirox, planned obsolescence is still alive and well.

Jerry dycus
User Rank
Re: Theories about reliability
Jerry dycus   4/5/2013 4:02:42 PM

  I remember a study on this many yrs ago and it compared quality between 2 cars, a Dodge Stealth and a Mitsubiti 365GT IIRC.

   The Dodge was rated much worse in quality, etc yet the fact was they were the same car off the same line and the only difference was the name badge.  That shows just how good subjective surveys can be. 

Especially when you see all the recalls, etc Japanese cars have had vs far less US ones doesn't seem to effect once something is in one's head it takes overwhelming evidence to get them to change.

Like the Repub saying, say it over and over again and it becomes true.

User Rank
Reliability, Quality and Staying in Business
MIROX   4/5/2013 3:05:13 PM
If you make the car too reliable and durable or easy to fix and repair, you will go out of business or be taken over by other companies.

Example Citroen, Rolls-Royce, Lada, etc.

And no matter how "bad" any car or how "good" any car statistically 50% of people will buy the same brand again, and 50% will want something "different" next time they buy vehicle.

Current vehicle advertising and promotions center about "infotainment" capabilities rather than anything else, and as we know any software and electronic technology is obsolete before you wear out your first set of tires.

Many years ago Porsche and Rolls-Royce were the ONLY two companies that carried spare parts for cars no longer in production, and both have given up on it.

In case of Porsche, some owners kept their cars for over 25 years, once the old part business was cancelled over 60% of them bought NEW Porsche, if they could no longer fix or maintain the old one conveniently.

In case of Rolls the value of the used cars plummeted and new vehicle sales collapsed as well. They auctioned off the entire RR inventory that dated back to 1930's one the Germans took them over.

And while sales of new Citroens in Europe are so so, there are people in France, Germany and Austria that make living keeping the DS 19 and 21 from 1960's still on the road and people will pay for them nearly the same price as they would for a new 2013 car.

But when you are OEM and make cars in millions the ultimate objective is to make profit and stay in business, reliability and durability are only important for "perception" which in consumer minds never matches with the reality anyway.

User Rank
Re: Water Running Vehicle
OLD_CURMUDGEON   4/5/2013 2:49:34 PM
far911:  The video that I saw very recently showed two fellows driving a battery-powered car "running on water", BUT the vehicle was designed in Israel, NOT Pakistan.  Maybe the Pakistani auto empire has something even more technologically advanced.... could it be???

User Rank
Re: No mystery here
Rigby5   4/5/2013 2:15:03 PM
Except JD Powers and Consumer Reports know very little about cars, and even less about reliability since they don't have to work on them after they are 10 years or more old.  It is pretty obvious that these magazines are just there to sell issues, are influenced by marketing more than engineering, and their results are based more on who gives them free loaners more than actual data.

User Rank
Asian cars not maintainable
Rigby5   4/5/2013 2:11:51 PM
The thesis is skewed.  While Asian cars have excellent quality control, their cars are not really reliable at all.   Because of their on demand view of supply, there can be over a half dozen different parts installed for any one component, over a period of time.  That makes parts distribution nearly impossible, and make long term maintenance terrible on Asian cars.  In contrast, it is much easier to get third party replacement parts for European cars.  Basing quality ratings on consumer polls from magazines is terribly biased.  The only real measure of reliability is resale value, and Europeans cars do much better than Asian.

<<  <  Page 6/9  >  >>
Partner Zone
More Blogs from Automotive News
General Motors is putting an off-road twist on hydrogen fuel cell technology with an imposing new pickup demonstrator called the Chevrolet Colorado ZH2.
The term “autopilot” is now at the heart of a growing debate between Tesla Motors Inc. and Germany’s Federal Motor Transport Authority.
Twenty months after news leaked about Apple Inc.’s secretive automotive project, the high-tech giant has apparently decided it will not go toe-to-toe with Detroit, leaving few in the Motor City surprised.
From the Corvair and the Pinto to the Gremlin and the Pacer, we’ve collected the worst vehicles that suffered from design and engineering hiccups.
Electric powertrains are stealing the spotlight, as automakers showcase their best and brightest battery-powered vehicles, during the Paris Motor Show, Oct. 1-16.
Quick Poll
The Continuing Education Center offers engineers an entirely new way to get the education they need to formulate next-generation solutions.
Oct 10 - 14, Embedded System Design Techniques™: Getting Started Developing Professional Embedded Software
SEMESTERS: 1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |  5  |  6 |  7 | 8 | 9 | 10

Focus on Fundamentals consists of 45-minute on-line classes that cover a host of technologies. You learn without leaving the comfort of your desk. All classes are taught by subject-matter experts and all are archived. So if you can't attend live, attend at your convenience.
Next Course September 27-29:
Sponsored by 3M
Learn More   |   Login   |   Archived Classes
Twitter Feed
Design News Twitter Feed
Like Us on Facebook

Technology Marketplace

Copyright © 2016 UBM Canon, A UBM company, All rights reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service