Guest Blogs

Petroski on Engineering: Checking In & Checking Out Design

< Previous Page 2 / 2
View Comments: Oldest First|Newest First|Threaded View
Page 1/2  >  >>
User Rank
Good Design is Memorable
williamlweaver   8/2/2012 7:41:07 AM
Thanks for your perfectly-worded descriptions. At first I thought you were setting up the story to reach a conclusion that good design should include empty space - but now I get the sense that good design should be integrated. I'm not sure how the Scottish decoration theme was integrated throughout the inn, but at least in the Star Trek universe, the Scots make the best engineers. Perhaps the inn was trying too hard to innovate. Good design appears effortless.

Beth Stackpole
User Rank
Re: Good Design is Memorable
Beth Stackpole   8/2/2012 8:25:55 AM
Thanks for putting good design in the context of everyday principles and everyday routines. Some times I think we get too caught up in the technical aspects and lose sight of the everyday nuances, which in the end, serve to make or break a product or experience.

Rob Spiegel
User Rank
Re: Good Design is Memorable
Rob Spiegel   8/2/2012 2:01:55 PM
Nice observations, Doc. I know exactly what you mean about hotel rooms. Sometimes they're great and sometimes you bump around in the room wondering why the room feels so uncomfortable. It can be very unnerving to spend a few days in a poorly designed room.

Dave Palmer
User Rank
Dave Palmer   8/2/2012 3:12:16 PM
About a year ago, while travelling for work, I stayed in a hotel in a small town in North Carolina in which the dresser was missing about half of its drawers.  It looked like something the owner had picked up from the side of the road.  The rest of the room didn't look much better.  The free breakfast consisted of Walmart cornflakes and milk from the owner's cupboard.

The owner was actually a very nice guy, and we had some interesting conversations, over Walmart cornflakes.  But I got a strong sense from these conversations that running a hotel was not what God created him for.

Also, after checking out, I found that he had charged my credit card twice.  It took over a month of phone calls from me and from the credit card company for him to reverse the charge.

For what it's worth, I've also stayed in $5 a night hotels in El Salvador and Guatemala, and had a much more enjoyable experience.

User Rank
naperlou   8/3/2012 8:57:17 AM
Thank you very much for a well written and entertaining artcile.  I laughed the whole way through.  It is always fun to try to understand the motivation for a design.  As with yourexperience of the hotel, this is an area where people from all walks experience the design.  Sometimes you have to wonder what they were thinking.

User Rank
Well, I never..
ChasChas   8/3/2012 10:53:38 AM

Being a machine design engineer, I never fully realized that someone actually designed my space (I mean put some serious thought into it) - I assumed it just happened via the current occupants. Anything that didn't work, change it, if it was easy to do it.

I remember a larger group of us went into a restaurant and wanted to be together so we pushed some tables together. The proprietor became so irate that he kicked us out.

Thus, my experience in ambience design. Great article.

User Rank
Re: Entertaining
RICKZ28   8/3/2012 2:14:47 PM
I agree, well written and entertaining to read.  I can certainly relate since I've stayed at many motels and hotels over the years.  Now-a-days, I read many customer reviews on the Internet about hotels before making a choice.  I've tended to have good luck choosing an acceptable hotel with a decent room.  While I never stay at motels anymore (yuk!), I am willing to pay a bit more for a better hotel and room.

When I remodeled my kitchen at home two years ago, the longest time period was my extensive design review.  (The second longest time was to pick the finishes with my wife...the cabinets, countertops and flooring.  I chose all the appliances myself after considerable review.)  I analyzed everything about my existing old kitchen, studied several different options for a new kitchen layout.  I even had five different design reviews with my kitchen guy (he was using a 3D kitchen design software), until I was satisfied that the finished design was perfect.  While I ended up with what looks like the same basic kitchen layout, I have countless refinements that made a huge difference.  All the time spent on the design (and finishes and appliances) was well worth the time and effort!  I enjoy my new kitchen every day when I'm at home, my wife and kids also.


User Rank
bobjengr   8/4/2012 1:00:42 PM
 This is a very entertaining article.   I did a great deal of international travel for two employers over my 40 + years of engineering.    During that time, I always marveled at differing design approaches to products and those manufacturing methods used to fabricate and assemble the designs.    Schools of thought between western and eastern designs can be quite striking when examined.   I was also "blown away" by the engineering capabilities of our Brazilian friends "down south".  I found them to be very well trained and extremely resourceful in their approach to basic engineering.  As engineers, we are trained to notice seemingly trivial things such as "room layout" but  the best engineers need this discipline to make any and all necessary improvements.  The powers of observation definitely factor into an individual's overall ability to find the root-cause relative problems found with equipment, components and assemblies.

William K.
User Rank
Design, beauty, and usability
William K.   8/4/2012 10:10:02 PM
It does appear that some motel rooms are designed by folks who NEVER had to do any work in them, or even spend any time in them. I am quite familiar with the small gap between the foot of the bed and the television cabinet. Actually, it would be interesting to find out if there are even rooms available without the television. My guess is "not." 

It must be that there is some other anticipated type of activity that engineers like us never participate in, but that the rooms were designed for.

It would be very interesting to hear from one of those designers as to what they were thinking about. Do we have any takers?

User Rank
Memorable British Design
ricardo   8/6/2012 10:37:18 PM
I dedicate the following link to my British Friends, some of whom are software engineers.


PS  Scots are British.

Page 1/2  >  >>
Partner Zone
More Blogs from Guest Blogs
Practically all electronic devices today contain metals that may be coming from conflict-ravaged African countries. And political pressures will increasingly influence how these minerals are sourced and used in products.
Conformal coatings present themselves as space-saving alternatives to enclosures for protecting the circuit boards of automotive electronics. They can also provide electrical insulation.
Design for manufacturing (DFM) in mold production means that mold designers evaluate the manufacturability of their molds in the early stage of mold development by collecting all relevant information and applying it to their designs. They also have to consider many other factors, including flow balance, structural stress, and assembly tolerance, in order to ensure successful molding production.
Some adhesives provide strong structural bonds but take hours to fixture and attain handling strength. The technologies that offer the fastest cure do not bear loads or withstand stresses. A new class of adhesives aims to make both stick.
The continued growth of wireless health is a near-certainty. And engineers will be the key to developing and advancing technology solutions.
Quick Poll
The Continuing Education Center offers engineers an entirely new way to get the education they need to formulate next-generation solutions.
Oct 10 - 14, Embedded System Design Techniques™: Getting Started Developing Professional Embedded Software
SEMESTERS: 1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |  5  |  6 |  7 | 8 | 9 | 10

Focus on Fundamentals consists of 45-minute on-line classes that cover a host of technologies. You learn without leaving the comfort of your desk. All classes are taught by subject-matter experts and all are archived. So if you can't attend live, attend at your convenience.
Next Course September 27-29:
Sponsored by 3M
Learn More   |   Login   |   Archived Classes
Twitter Feed
Design News Twitter Feed
Like Us on Facebook

Technology Marketplace

Copyright © 2016 UBM Canon, A UBM company, All rights reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service