Guest Blogs

Solyndra Seeds Doubts About Photovoltaic Manufacturability

Page 1 / 2 Next >
View Comments: Newest First|Oldest First|Threaded View
<<  <  Page 2/2
Loring Wirbel
User Rank
Re: Solyndra Proving USA Solar not workable
Loring Wirbel   11/7/2011 11:09:26 AM
Amen to all, Harpo - seems as though the auditors in the federal government got overruled for obvious reasons - and the venture community needs better reality-check auditors, too!

User Rank
Solyndra Proving USA Solar not workable
Harpo-54   11/7/2011 11:03:31 AM
The analysis should have been simple for Solyndra, the DOE and everybody here forward... How can you blow a half a billion dollars when given:

Standard Solar PV Panels = $2500 per kilowatt

Solyndra Solar PV Panels = $6000 per kilowatt

The long term analysis of "payback", that point at which the cost of a standard  solar kW unit of panels supplying all that  "free" power" long  enough  that your cost of energy = about 12 cents per killowat hour, paying for the initial investment  is  about 10 to 18 years with standard solar.

So a Solyndra panel would "payback in 24 to 34 years"..  Nobody knows if they would even last that long...  The material studies are theoretical at least and based on accelerated environmental testing at best.   Talk to battery companies about their predictive powers when it comes to end of life...

The moment the cost per Solyndra Solar Kw got a penny higher than the standard tech Kw,  alarms should have been going of in everybody's head and big RED LETTERS should have been showing up on spreadsheets.

Bottom line...  Electric Utility Power is a commodity item not a vanity item..  Except in special cases  (like a PV powered Oil Well)  the actual rate of return on PV energy does yet not pay for itself at 13 to 18% efficiency.  Maybe it will at 45%...


Loring Wirbel
User Rank
Re: Solar masnufacturing
Loring Wirbel   11/7/2011 10:38:54 AM
J-allen, very good points about cadmium telluride.  I notice that many people in the thin-film industry outside solar panels have been touting the use of lead-free perovskites and similar RoHS-compliant materials.  It would be good if green energy companies emphasize the green nature of the entire manufacturing process - which includes addressing the waste concerns of an old panel, just as assuredly as nuclear must include the waste.

Loring Wirbel
User Rank
Re: Point Solutions
Loring Wirbel   11/7/2011 10:38:18 AM
cvandewater, that was precisely why I made the point about China virtually owning the PV panel market.  There are only rare instances where a company outside Asia can show manufacturing advantages.  But that does not give Chinese companies a guaranteed market either, as SunTech's recent stumbles show.  The alternative-energy market is demonstrating growing pains worldwide.


User Rank
Solar masnufacturing
j-allen   11/7/2011 9:34:42 AM
Most new technologies have had a history of many companies entering the market with many of them failing or being absorbed or merged.  Consider automobiles and aircraft in the early 20th century, also radio and TV manufacturers.


In the case of solar, there is a good reason for public subsidy , given the externalities of fossil fuel combustion.  These cost the public in many direct and indirect ways. 


As foir First Solar, their product has a special problem resulting from the cadmium telluride active material.   Years from now when the panels are discarded, they will very likely end up busted in a dump.   We conducted a series of experiments where we put broken samples of CdTe PV panels in aqueous solutions with pH values of 7 (distilled water), 6, 5, 4, and 3. for about 4 months.  

In all but the distilled water, the cadmium leached out into solution and for pH values of 5 and below virtually ALL the cadmium went into solution.   Given the toxicity of Cd and the tons of panels that will end up in dumps, that is a serious threat to groundwater. 


The manufacturers have promised to collect the dead panels in 25 or 30 years and reclaim the cadmium, but the funding for this is far from sufficient and who knows what will happen between now and then?


Customers and regulatory agencies are getting wise to the CdTe problem and turning to other less poisonous kinds of panels. 



User Rank
Re: Point Solutions
cvandewater   11/7/2011 9:29:04 AM
I think the article (and its title) are exemplary of a focus on USA & the west alone. When I look how the Solar manufacturing industry here in India and in China are exploding (without much subsidy, but with encouragements like SEZ and low laber cost) then I think you can understand why I read the title as:

"Solyndra seeds doubts about Photovoltaic manufacturability... in USA."

I have no doubt of the strong flow of PV panels from India and China where there is a decent ROI for the systems installed with these (low cost) panels, so there is no doubt about viability, even *without* local subsidies. Just allow feed-in tarif at the mid day price level and you will see how the ROI period shrinks to make the PV industry a success, just that manufacturing will be done elsewhere, so we know where we need to focus to be successful!

Loring Wirbel
User Rank
Re: Point Solutions
Loring Wirbel   11/4/2011 10:53:43 AM
TJ, I'm personally not a huge fan of large centralized nuke or coal plants, but I think you have identified the source of the problem for decentralized point sources, and it's one T. Boone Pickens referred to when giving up on his wind farms.  The power grid in this country is antiquated, and the DOE's funding of smart grid software only solves half the problem.  The physical transmission lines and their support facilities need to be restructured and prepared for an underlying smart grid, and where wiill the capital investment come from for that?  Intriguing questions, all.

TJ McDermott
User Rank
Point Solutions
TJ McDermott   11/4/2011 9:24:54 AM
A colleague and I were talking about power companies and their sources, and about point solutions.  I was arguing strongly that we needed a LOT more nuclear plants in this country; he said power companies needed diverse sources.

I don't think either of us is wrong.

I would not want to be one of a power company's diverse alternative sources; wind farms in Washington State were shafted this summer when they were asked to shut down because there was too much hydro power available.  The investment to plant a wind farm is too great for this type of "request".  The power company should have been selling the excess to other states.



<<  <  Page 2/2
Partner Zone
More Blogs from Guest Blogs
Practically all electronic devices today contain metals that may be coming from conflict-ravaged African countries. And political pressures will increasingly influence how these minerals are sourced and used in products.
Conformal coatings present themselves as space-saving alternatives to enclosures for protecting the circuit boards of automotive electronics. They can also provide electrical insulation.
Design for manufacturing (DFM) in mold production means that mold designers evaluate the manufacturability of their molds in the early stage of mold development by collecting all relevant information and applying it to their designs. They also have to consider many other factors, including flow balance, structural stress, and assembly tolerance, in order to ensure successful molding production.
Some adhesives provide strong structural bonds but take hours to fixture and attain handling strength. The technologies that offer the fastest cure do not bear loads or withstand stresses. A new class of adhesives aims to make both stick.
The continued growth of wireless health is a near-certainty. And engineers will be the key to developing and advancing technology solutions.
Quick Poll
The Continuing Education Center offers engineers an entirely new way to get the education they need to formulate next-generation solutions.
Oct 10 - 14, Embedded System Design Techniques™: Getting Started Developing Professional Embedded Software
SEMESTERS: 1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |  5  |  6 |  7 | 8 | 9 | 10

Focus on Fundamentals consists of 45-minute on-line classes that cover a host of technologies. You learn without leaving the comfort of your desk. All classes are taught by subject-matter experts and all are archived. So if you can't attend live, attend at your convenience.
Next Course September 27-29:
Sponsored by 3M
Learn More   |   Login   |   Archived Classes
Twitter Feed
Design News Twitter Feed
Like Us on Facebook

Technology Marketplace

Copyright © 2016 UBM Canon, A UBM company, All rights reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service